Utopia Talk / Politics / seb goes back in time

Sam Adams rank	Tue Apr 21 23:51:29 https://x.com/DailyGondor/status/2042197939548835871?s=20
Seb rank	Wed Apr 22 07:49:43 The most depressing thing about the alt-right's appropriation of Tolkien is how *thoroughly* they have read the books to capture all sorts of details while absorbing not a single iota of the meaning.
williamthebastard rank	Wed Apr 22 10:16:07 Tolkein was always vulnerable. A bit too fascinated with dividing subjects into good and bad races, as was the current trend in those times.
Seb rank	Wed Apr 22 11:05:41 WtB: That's also not what he was doing. Orks exist because Sauron and Melkor need minions from a narrative perspective. The entire point of most of the rest of the novel is all people have the capacity for good, all people are redeemable. He then spent the rest of his life trying to reconcile his actual theological views on race, free will, redemption and the divine as applied to Orks. If they are created by God, they must have free will and individually capable of redemption. They cannot be created by melkor, because evil cannot create and give a soul. But narratively he wanted a group of generic loyal badies. At a very fundamental level he absolutely did not believe in the idea of good and bad races and the existence of Orks was in his mind a plot hole.
williamthebastard rank	Wed Apr 22 11:13:03 Hes subconsciously thinking far too much about races for his own good. Thats obvious. You can even trace them to humans, the blond elves are clearly Nordic for example, the Hobbits are clearly the idealistic version of honest, down-to-Earth English workers, who like a friendly pint after a day mending the house, salt of the earth dont you know
williamthebastard rank	Wed Apr 22 11:16:02 Theres nothing saintly about famous figures. You are allowed to criticize them, you dont have to be in hallowed awe like americans are of celebrities. Common criticism of Tolkein is that he was reflecting one aspect of the racial discourse of his time without realizing it, and another is that he wasnt a particularly elegant stylist. There are, of course, lots of positive things to be said about him as well
williamthebastard rank	Wed Apr 22 11:22:02 "He then spent the rest of his life trying to reconcile his actual theological views on race" So he himself obviously saw parallels to racial theory in his writings if he felt he had to spend the rest of his life on that topic
	show deleted posts

Your Name:
Your Password:
Your Message: